Choosing the right background screening provider can make a significant difference in how quickly a staffing agency places candidates, meets client requirements, and manages hiring compliance. When recruiters are handling dozens or even hundreds of applicants, delays in background checks can affect placement timelines, candidate experience, and revenue.
Three providers staffing agencies may consider are Intelifi, Checkr, and Sterling. Each offers employment background screening services, but their platforms, integrations, support models, and service approaches differ.
So, when comparing Intelifivs. Checkr vs. Sterling, which provider is best for staffing agencies?
The answer depends on your agency's hiring volume, technology requirements, screening needs, budget, and preferred level of customer support. This guide compares the three providers to help staffing professionals make a more informed decision.
Quick Comparison: Intelifi vs. Checkr vs. Sterling

Comparison based on publicly available provider information. Features, integrations, pricing, and service availability can vary by contract, account, and screening package. Confirm current details directly with each provider.
1. Intelifi: Staffing-Focused Screening With Personalized Support
Intelifi provides background screening solutions specifically designed to support staffing agencies and employment organizations. Its services help recruiters evaluate candidates, verify qualifications, and manage screening requirements across different roles and locations.
With more than 15 years of experience serving staffing organizations, Intelifi emphasizes a combination of screening technology, customizable packages, and dedicated customer support. Its staffing solutions are designed for agencies that need to process candidates efficiently without sacrificing report quality or personal assistance.
Key Features of Intelifi
Comprehensive background screening
Intelifi offers a range of screening services, including:
- County, state, and federal criminal background checks
- People searches
- Employment history verification
- Education verification
- Professional license verification
- Motor vehicle records
- Credit reporting
- Drug testing
Agencies can select screening products based on job responsibilities, client requirements, and their internal hiring policies.
Emerge screening platform
Intelifi's Emerge platform is designed to simplify the background screening process. It combines screening technology, customizable packages, and human review to help produce clear and useful reports.
The platform also uses AI-assisted report analysis alongside human oversight to help identify potential inaccuracies and improve report clarity.
LiveRunner direct-source technology
Intelifi's LiveRunner technology connects with county courthouses and other record sources. Intelifi states that certain county and state records can be retrieved in as little as one to two hours when the information is accessible.
This can help staffing agencies move candidates through screening more efficiently. However, actual completion times depend on the jurisdiction, search scope, and availability of records.
ATS and software integrations
Intelifi supports integrations with platforms including Bullhorn, iCIMS, and Oracle Taleo. Its Open API also allows for custom integration possibilities with other HR and applicant tracking systems.
For staffing agencies that want to reduce manual data entry and streamline candidate onboarding, integration capabilities are an important consideration.
Dedicated account management
One of Intelifi's key differentiators is its relationship-based support model. The company provides dedicated account managers and a U.S.-based support team to assist customers with screening questions, platform use, and account needs.
This approach may appeal to agencies that prefer direct communication and a more personalized service relationship.
Potential Advantages for Staffing Agencies
- Screening packages that can be customized for different job types and client requirements
- A broad selection of background screening and verification services
- Staffing-focused experience
- ATS integration options and Open API capabilities
- Direct-source technology for certain county and state records
- Dedicated account management and support
Things to Consider
Agencies should request a customized quote and confirm which integrations, screening packages, service levels, and turnaround expectations apply to their specific account. They should also test the platform against their actual hiring workflow before making a long-term commitment.
Learn more about Intelifi's background screening solutions for staffing agencies.
2. Checkr: Automation and Technology for High-Volume Hiring
Checkr is a background screening provider known for its technology-driven approach, automated workflows, and candidate-facing tools. It offers solutions for staffing companies that need to process large numbers of applicants and manage screening activity efficiently.
Its staffing solutions emphasize faster candidate processing, visibility into screening progress, and integration with existing recruitment systems.
Key Features of Checkr
Automated screening workflows
Checkr offers tools designed to simplify the background check process, reduce manual tasks, and help recruiters manage candidate screening at scale.
Its technology includes estimated completion times that can help staffing teams plan onboarding and candidate start dates.
Bullhorn integration
Checkr offers a Bullhorn integration that allows staffing agencies to initiate background checks, view estimated completion times, and manage candidate screening within their recruiting workflow.
The integration can help reduce duplicate data entry and improve visibility into screening progress.
Candidate experience tools
Checkr provides a mobile-friendly candidate portal where applicants can complete required steps and follow the status of their background checks.
This can help reduce unnecessary communication between candidates and recruiters.
Broad integration ecosystem
Checkr states that it supports more than 200 integrations across ATS, HRIS, and payroll platforms. Agencies using multiple recruitment and workforce management tools may find this ecosystem valuable.
Published pricing options
Checkr publicly lists starting prices for certain background check packages, including Basic, Essential, and Complete options. Additional services and third-party access fees may affect the final cost.
Enterprise customers can request customized pricing.
Potential Advantages for Staffing Agencies
- Strong focus on automation and workflow efficiency
- Bullhorn integration
- Broad ATS and HRIS integration ecosystem
- Candidate-facing screening tools
- Published starting prices for selected packages
- Screening ETA features
Things to Consider
Agencies should review the total cost of their required screening packages, including additional services and applicable third-party fees. They should also confirm whether the available automation, integrations, and support arrangements match their operational needs.
Checkr may be especially worth evaluating for staffing companies that prioritize technology integrations, candidate self-service, and high-volume screening workflows.
Learn more about Checkr's background check services for staffing agencies.
3. Sterling: Established Screening Capabilities for Enterprise Needs
Sterling has long been recognized as an employment background screening provider serving organizations across different industries. Its services have supported employers with criminal background checks, employment screening, verification, and related workforce risk management needs.
An important consideration for agencies evaluating Sterling today is that Sterling was acquired by First Advantage. Staffing firms should therefore confirm the current product offering, account structure, pricing, and support arrangements when evaluating or renewing a Sterling relationship.
Key Features and Capabilities
Employment background screening
Sterling's screening services have included criminal record searches, employment verification, identity-related screening, and other employment background check products.
The exact services available should be confirmed with the current First Advantage team.
Recruiting platform integrations
Sterling has established integrations with recruiting and HR platforms. For example, its Greenhouse integration has supported background check ordering, status updates, and access to completed reports within the recruiting platform.
Sterling is also listed as a background screening integration in the Dayforce partner ecosystem.
Enterprise screening experience
Organizations with complex hiring requirements may consider Sterling's established screening operations and enterprise-oriented service capabilities.
Staffing agencies with multiple locations, specialized roles, and varied client requirements should evaluate whether the current offering supports their specific workflows.
Potential Advantages for Staffing Agencies
- Established employment screening history
- Recruiting and HR platform integration options
- Broad background screening experience
- Potential fit for organizations with existing Sterling relationships
- Enterprise-oriented screening capabilities
Things to Consider
Because Sterling is now part of First Advantage, agencies should clarify which platform and services they will receive, how existing integrations are supported, and who will manage their account.
They should also compare current pricing, implementation requirements, turnaround expectations, and support arrangements with other providers before making a decision.
For agencies considering Sterling, the best approach is to request a current proposal and confirm that the offered solution fits their staffing operations.
Intelifi vs. Checkr vs. Sterling: Which Provider Is Best for Your Staffing Agency?
There is no single provider that is automatically best for every staffing organization. The right choice depends on the agency's operational priorities.
Here is a practical way to approach the decision:

When Intelifi May Be the Better Fit
Intelifi may be a strong option for staffing agencies that value personalized support, customizable screening packages, and a provider with direct experience serving staffing and employment organizations.
Its combination of Emerge technology, LiveRunner direct-source capabilities, human-reviewed reports, and dedicated account management is worth considering for agencies that want more than a self-service screening platform.
Agencies that use Bullhorn, iCIMS, or Oracle Taleo may also want to explore Intelifi's integration options.
When Checkr May Be the Better Fit
Checkr may be a good fit for agencies that prioritize automation, candidate-facing tools, estimated screening completion times, and a broad integration ecosystem.
Its Bullhorn integration is particularly relevant to staffing firms that want to manage screening within their existing recruiting workflow.
When Sterling May Be the Better Fit
Sterling may remain worth considering for staffing organizations with existing Sterling relationships, established enterprise workflows, or specific integration requirements.
However, because Sterling is now part of First Advantage, agencies should evaluate the current offering and support model rather than relying only on older product information or past experiences.
7 Questions to Ask Before Choosing a Background Screening Provider
Before signing a contract, staffing agencies should compare providers using their actual screening requirements.
Consider asking these questions:
- How quickly can the provider complete common screening searches? Ask for typical timelines by search type and location rather than relying on a single advertised turnaround time.
- Does the platform integrate with our ATS? Confirm whether the integration is already available, requires custom development, or involves additional fees.
- Can we customize screening packages? Different clients and job positions may require different screening components.
- What is included in the quoted price? Ask about package fees, court access fees, verification charges, drug testing, and other potential costs.
- How are reports reviewed for accuracy? Understand the provider's processes for identifying potential mismatches and handling disputed information.
- What customer support is available? Ask whether your agency will have a dedicated account manager and what support channels and response expectations apply.
- How does the provider support compliance? Confirm how the provider helps customers follow applicable FCRA, state, and local requirements.
Background Screening Compliance Matters for Every Staffing Agency
Regardless of which provider you choose, background screening must be handled responsibly.
In the United States, the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) establishes requirements for employers that obtain and use consumer reports for employment decisions. These requirements include providing appropriate disclosures, obtaining authorization, and following required procedures before and after adverse employment actions.
Staffing agencies should also consider applicable state and local laws, as well as federal equal employment opportunity requirements.
Using a screening provider does not eliminate an agency's responsibility to follow the laws that apply to its hiring and placement practices.
For additional guidance, review the Federal Trade Commission's employer background check guidance.
Final Verdict: Intelifi vs. Checkr vs. Sterling
When comparing Intelifi vs. Checkr vs. Sterling, the best provider depends on what your staffing agency needs most.
- Intelifi is worth considering for staffing-focused screening, customizable packages, direct-source technology, and personalized account management.
- Checkr stands out for automation, candidate experience tools, and a broad integration ecosystem.
- Sterling / First Advantage may be suitable for organizations evaluating established enterprise screening capabilities or maintaining existing Sterling workflows.
For staffing agencies looking for a combination of screening services, flexible packages, technology, and hands-on support, Intelifi deserves a place on the shortlist.
The best way to determine whether Intelifi is right for your agency is to compare your current screening workflow, required services, integration needs, and total costs.
Ready to improve your staffing agency's background screening process?
Explore Intelifi's staffing and employment background screening solutions or contact Intelifi to discuss your agency's screening requirements.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Intelifi better than Checkr for staffing agencies?
Intelifi may be a better fit for agencies that prioritize personalized account management, customizable screening packages, and staffing-focused service. Checkr may be preferable for agencies that prioritize automation, candidate self-service, and a broad integration ecosystem. The best choice depends on the agency's workflow and requirements.
What is the difference between Intelifi and Checkr?
Both companies provide employment background screening services. Intelifi emphasizes staffing-focused packages, direct-source technology, human-reviewed reports, and dedicated account management. Checkr emphasizes automated screening workflows, candidate-facing tools, estimated completion times, and extensive integrations.
Is Sterling still a separate background screening company?
Sterling was acquired by First Advantage. Agencies evaluating Sterling should confirm the current platform, product availability, contracting arrangements, and support structure directly with First Advantage.
Which background check company integrates with Bullhorn?
Intelifi and Checkr both identify Bullhorn among their integration options. Agencies should confirm the available integration features, implementation process, and any associated fees with each provider.
How much do staffing agency background checks cost?
Costs vary based on the screening package, search locations, verification requirements, drug testing, and additional fees. Checkr publishes starting prices for selected packages, while Intelifi and Sterling-related enterprise services should be quoted based on the agency's requirements. Request an itemized proposal before comparing total costs.
What should staffing agencies look for in a background screening provider?
Staffing agencies should evaluate screening coverage, turnaround times, accuracy procedures, ATS integrations, pricing, customer support, package flexibility, and compliance resources. A provider should be able to support the agency's actual hiring volume and client requirements.
Are background checks through Intelifi, Checkr, and Sterling FCRA compliant?
Each provider offers employment screening services intended for use within applicable compliance frameworks. However, compliance depends on the services used and how the staffing agency obtains, evaluates, and acts on background information. Agencies should follow the FCRA and applicable state and local laws, and consult qualified legal counsel when necessary.
Disclaimer: This article is for general informational purposes and is not legal advice or an independent audit of any provider. Provider features, pricing, integrations, and corporate arrangements may change. Confirm current details directly with each company before making a purchasing decision.

No comments:
Post a Comment